In order to fulfill the basic functions of our service, the user hereby agrees to allow Xiaomi to collect, process and use personal information which shall include but not be limited to written threads, pictures, comments, replies in the Mi Community, and relevant data types listed in Xiaomi's Private Policy. By selecting "Agree", you agree to Xiaomi's Private Policy and Content Policy .
Agree

Redmi Note 5 Pro

[Discussion] Revert Changes in Portrait Mode of RN5 Pro

2018-03-15 08:49:40
8429 156
Hi All,

Xiaomi launched Redmi Note 5 Pro last month and we all know it is a Beast when it comes to the camera in its segment. The camera on Redmi Note 5 Pro is one of the highly talked about topic and it even challenges many of the other smartphones which are from a higher segment. One of the most important features of this camera is the Portrait mode. We have seen that it captures mindblowing portraits. This post is about this Portrait mode and how a recent change actually takes it one step backwards.

The recent MIUI Update (V9.2.5.0) changed the way the Portrait mode works on the Redmi Note 5 Pro. There are two observations I would like to discuss here:

1. Portrait Zoom
Now, when you open the Camera in Portrait mode, the Object/Subject gets zoomed in. This is the same behaviour that's there on Mi A1 (which was great on A1).
However here on Redmi Note 5 Pro, this actually degrades the quality of the picture. Mi A1 had a Telephoto lens which helped in lossless zooming thereby keeping the quality intact; whereas Redmi Note 5 Pro doesn't have a Telephoto lens to give that lossless zoom. And since it works on Digital zoom here, the final output is slightly grainy and not as great as it used to be.
(1 - Normal Mode, 2 - Portrait Mode)
2. 12MP to 5MP
Prior to V9.2.5.0 Update, photos taken from rear camera (both normal mode & portrait mode) were of the same resolution (4000 x 3000 px), which indicated the use of the 12MP sensor at the rear.
But after the update, this has changed. Normal mode pics still come in 4000 x 3000 px resolution, but the Portrait mode pics are in 2752 x 2064 px, which indicates the use of the 5MP camera. Why is it like that?

(1 - Normal Mode, 2 - Portrait Mode)

These two things may be connected and interdependent. Maybe because of the usage of the 5MP sensor, the images are zoomed in.
(I have attached original images to this thread which proves these observations)

The reply we usually receive is that it's by design. But what's the point, if the quality is degraded and it gives a bad user experience?

So, It's a request to Xiaomi India to revert this change and make it how it was earlier. Allow Portrait mode pics to be captured by the 12MP sensor, and remove this zoom-in feature for Portrait mode completely on Redmi Note 5 Pro. Also, if at all a zoom-in feature is required, give the users an option to Enable/Disable this default zoom. And possibly set the Zoom option to OFF by default.

To All Mi Fans,
We know that Xiaomi listens to their Mi Fans, and take their feedback seriously.
If you agree with these observations, please vote* on this thread, give your feedback on this topic and make your voice heard.
I hope Xiaomi India notices this and take the right steps to ensure we get best quality pictures and the best UX.



(* Voting option available below)
Single Poll thread Total 550 Users Voted This Poll has ended.
 
37.82% (208)
 
55.45% (305)
 
6.73% (37)
Submit

Rate

Number of participants 3 Experience +17 Pack Reason

View Rating Log

2018-03-15 08:49:40
Favorites30 RateRate

Mi FC President

Bingo220 | from Redmi Note 5 Pro

#1

Completely agree with you bhai... Either completely disable it.... Or if u dnt want to disable then atkeast give us option to disable or enable it
2018-03-15 09:35:56
Need Help? PM me or Tag me in your Post.
Mi FC Pune President.

Mi FC President

Amit Kumar Panda | from Redmi Note 5 Pro

#2


Zoom should be option not mandatory
2018-03-15 09:39:12
[img]https://in.c.mi.com/https://in.c.mi.com/https://u01.appmifile.com/images/2018/08/01/46fac8a5-2

Moderator

HiteshJ | from Redmi Note 5 Pro

#3

Totally agree with you..
2018-03-15 09:40:41
Don't worry be Happy :)
Completely agree with you! It's better to give option to enable and disable the same, so the ones who need can use and the ones who don't need can turn it off!
2018-03-15 09:42:24

Mi FC President

Prouser90 | from Mi MIX 2

#5

Totally agree with you. As Redmi Note 5 Pro doesn't have the telephoto lense so it would be better to remove the zoom feature.
2018-03-15 09:42:38
Please revert the changes in Portrait mode. If you want to keep it, give us an option to disable !
2018-03-15 09:43:07
I agree to you wholeheartedly. The recent update makes the back camera portrait worse. It's almost useless now. The low-light portrait, which was the key attraction of this phone, is terrible now.
2018-03-15 09:46:17

Mi FC President

Riturajboss | from Redmi Note 4

#8

Yes, agree with you
2018-03-15 09:47:37

Pro Bunny

VTiwari | from Redmi Note 5 Pro

#9

totally agree with you it shouldn't be mandatory
2018-03-15 09:48:48

Master Bunny

Vizard | from Redmi Note 5 Pro

#10

Definitely remove this zoom , earlier portrait performance was beastly , but 9.2.5 update made the portrait worse , i totally agree with you .
2018-03-15 09:50:41
please sign in to reply.
Sign In Sign Up

SuzAnDroid

Mi FC President

  • Followers

    1975

  • Threads

    32

  • Replies

    373

  • Points

    5039

Beta Tester
MIUI 8
India 2nd year
100K members
Redmi 3S
6th MIUI
Independence Day
3 Days Check-In
7 Days Check-In
Shake!!Shake!!
Lucky Draw No.
500K Members
Mi Explorers
1st Anniversary
Mi Community Updater
Throwback With Mi 2018

Read moreGet new
Copyright©2016-2019 Xiaomi.com, All Rights Reserved
Content Policy
Quick Reply To Top Return to the list